top of page

Is Your House Too Small—or Do You Just Need to Get More Organized?

Writer: Heather Nicholson
Heather Nicholson
Oct 5
7 min read

By Zeb and Heather Nicholson, REALTORS® serving Cedar Falls, Waterloo, and the Cedar Valley

Backyard of a gray house with large text: Maybe the bins aren’t the problem, and smaller text: Have you outgrown your house?

There comes a point when we have to admit the bins may not be the problem.

You know the cycle.

The closet stops working, so you reorganize it. You buy bins. Maybe matching bins this time, because apparently visual consistency is what has been standing between your household and inner peace.

It works.

For a while.


Then somehow the closet is full again. The dining room has become an office-slash-homework-station-slash-drop-zone. The kitchen appliances are migrating to other parts of the house. You have to move the stroller to get to the mower, move the Christmas decorations to get to the camping gear, and move three things off the counter before you can actually use the counter.


So you decide:

We really need to get more organized.

And maybe you do.

But maybe you’re trying to solve a house problem with organization.

Those are two very different problems—and knowing which one you actually have can save you a lot of frustration, a lot of money, and possibly your fifth trip to buy another set of storage bins.


Sometimes it really is an organization problem

We should get this out of the way first, especially considering we're REALTORS®:

Not every crowded house means you need a different house.


Sometimes you have too much stuff.

Sometimes the closet genuinely needs a better shelving system. Sometimes a room isn't being used particularly well. Sometimes you haven't gone through the basement since you moved in, and there are six boxes down there you haven't opened in eight years.


Moving doesn't magically solve any of those things. In fact, it mostly means you get to put all of those things into boxes, pay someone to move them, and discover them again at your next house.


Before deciding your house is the problem, it's worth giving organization a fair shot.

Declutter what you genuinely don't use. Pay attention to spaces that aren't functioning well. Think about whether furniture could be arranged differently. Look for unused vertical space. Ask whether everything you're trying to store actually needs to live where it currently lives.


But here's the important part:

What happens after you've already done that?

Because if you've reorganized the same problem four different ways and the problem keeps coming back, it might be time to investigate further.


Sign #1: You've decluttered, but normal life keeps filling the space again

There's a difference between a house being full because it contains too much stuff and a house being full because it contains the normal belongings of the people who live there.

That distinction matters.


Maybe you've already donated the clothes nobody wears. The baby gear is gone. The mystery basement boxes have finally been dealt with. You've pared down the kitchen cabinets and made the obligatory trip to donate approximately 37 coffee mugs.

And the house still feels crowded.


Worse, every time you get it under control, simply living there seems to undo your work.

That's useful information.

If the problem returns because new clutter continually accumulates, you may need better habits or organization.

If the problem returns because the things your family regularly uses simply don't have enough functional space, organization can only take you so far.


At some point, we have to stop accusing the laundry basket.


Sign #2: Your rooms are doing too many jobs

Multipurpose spaces aren't inherently bad.

Especially in some of the older homes we see around Cedar Falls and Waterloo, houses weren't necessarily designed around the way we live today. Cedar Falls' own housing data reflects a community with housing built across many decades, including a significant amount dating well before today's work-from-home setups and modern expectations for how we use space.


A dining room that doubles as an office? Fine.

A guest room that doubles as a workout room? Makes sense.


But there's a point where multipurpose becomes constant compromise.

Maybe the dining room is an office, homework station, craft area, storage room and occasionally a place where someone would like to eat dinner.

Maybe one parent works from the bedroom because there isn't anywhere else to take a Zoom call.

Maybe toys have taken over the living room not because nobody puts them away, but because there genuinely isn't another place for kids to play.

Maybe you've reached the point where every new function your household needs has to be squeezed into a room that already has two.


That's less about organization and more about what you're asking the house to do.


Sign #3: You have to move something to use something else

This is one of our favorite ways to think about whether a space is actually working:

How much friction does the house create?

You shouldn't necessarily need a giant house. But your house should make ordinary life reasonably easy.


If you have to move the stroller every time you need the mower, that's friction.

If the appliances have to come off the kitchen counter every time you cook, that's friction.

If toys have to be relocated every time you eat dinner, that's friction.

If getting something out of the basement requires moving an entire seasonal display of Christmas decorations first, that's definitely friction.


None of these things individually means anything.

But when your entire house starts operating this way—move this to access that, put this here temporarily, move it back later—you may not actually have a clutter problem.

You may have a space problem.


Sign #4: Everything has a place. It's just a terrible place.

Organization advice loves the phrase:

A place for everything and everything in its place.

Fair enough.

But we'd like to add a small amendment:

The place should make some damn sense.


If the kitchen appliance you use three times a week lives in the basement because there's nowhere for it in the kitchen, technically it has a place.

If everyone's coats are distributed among three different closets because no single closet can accommodate them, they all have places.

If the everyday thing lives behind the once-a-year thing because that's the only configuration that fits, congratulations: organized.

But not particularly functional.


“It fits” and “this works” are not the same thing.

That's an important distinction when you're deciding whether another shelving unit will solve the problem.


Sign #5: Your house worked before. Your life changed.

This may be the biggest one.

A lot of homeowners assume that deciding they need something different means there's something wrong with their current house.

There doesn't have to be.

Maybe you bought your first Cedar Falls home when there were two of you.

Then a kid arrived.

Then another.


Someone started working from home.

The hobbies multiplied. The kids got bigger. Their stuff got bigger. Somehow everyone in the family acquired three water bottles.

The house didn't suddenly become a bad house.


The household changed.

That's particularly relevant for people living in a first home or a house they bought relatively early in adulthood. What you needed at 27 may not be what you need at 35.

And that's normal.


Cedar Falls itself has been examining whether its housing supply matches residents' needs in terms of size, condition and amenities; the city's 2023 Housing Needs Assessment specifically identified that fit as one of the questions facing the community.


At the individual-household level, we're asking a much simpler version of the same question:

Does the house you have still fit the life you're living?


Here's how to tell whether you have an organization problem or a house problem

Try a thought experiment.

Imagine that while you're sleeping tonight, someone comes into your house and organizes absolutely everything.

Not in the creepy way that sentence sounds.

They declutter everything you don't want. Every closet works. Every bin is labeled. Every toy has a home. Every kitchen appliance has been put somewhere sensible. The basement is immaculate.


You wake up tomorrow morning and:

Everything you own magically has a designated place.

Now ask yourself:

Would the house still feel too small?


If your answer is no, that's actually great news.

You may have an organization problem.

You can start looking at decluttering, storage solutions, furniture arrangement or changing how you're using individual rooms. You may be able to make your current house work beautifully for several more years.


But if the answer is yes, that's worth paying attention to.

You may not be trying to store too much stuff.

You may be asking your house to accommodate more life than it comfortably can.


A house problem doesn't automatically mean you should move

This is where we don't want to make the opposite mistake.

Realizing your house doesn't perfectly fit your life does not automatically mean:

Welp. Better put it on the market.

There are other questions to answer.


Could you finish part of the basement?

Would changing the layout solve the biggest issue?

Could a remodel give you what you're missing?

Would an addition make financial sense?

Do you love the neighborhood enough that making the house work is worth the investment?

And, importantly: what would it cost to make this house work compared with what it would cost to move into a house that already does?


That's where the conversation gets more interesting.

Because the problem isn't really:

Should we sell our house?

It's:

What are we trying to change about our everyday life, and what's the smartest way to change it?

Sometimes the answer will be better organization.

Sometimes it's a renovation.

Sometimes it's accepting one annoying closet because you love everything else about where you live.

And yes, sometimes the answer is starting to look at what another house could give you.


You don't have to be ready to move to start asking the question

We think this is one of the strangest assumptions people make about talking to a real estate agent.

You don't need to have made a decision first.


In fact, “We don't know if we should move” is a perfectly reasonable place to start.

For homeowners in Cedar Falls, Waterloo and throughout the Cedar Valley, that might mean looking at what your current home could realistically sell for, what your next-house budget might look like, what kinds of homes could actually solve the problems you're having, and whether moving makes enough sense to pursue.


Maybe you look at all of that and decide:

Nope. We're buying better shelves.

Excellent.

Now you know.


Or maybe you discover that you've spent the last three years rearranging the same 200 square feet because what your family actually needs is something your current house can't provide.

That's useful to know, too.

Because before you solve a problem, you need to know which problem you're actually solving.

And sometimes—

it's the bins.

Sometimes it's the house.

Comments


bottom of page